The COMELEC recently posted a list of registered voters online, “in pursuit of transparency to the end that the stakeholders in our election will trust COMELEC more.”
Unfortunately, the list also includes the registrants’ addresses, birthdays, date of registration, and where they have to vote come Election 2007. It’s by no means comprehensive (the names of family and some friends are missing), and it apparently covers only the NCR. But the personal information of thousands, if not millions, of Filipinos are now available for public consumption.
Even addresses and birthdays aren’t something we usually try to hide, that’s beside the point. There’s a reason why people value their privacy highly. There are many ways to exploit knowledge of a person’s location and age. I’m sure such freely-available demographic info will be a gold mine for unscrupulous marketers. And henchmen looking to silence vocal critics of their boss. Like Marrku said: “A little of connect–this and connect–that will get you more information than you’re ever supposed to know.”
Ironically, what the COMELEC did may have made people less confident about the elections. The committee’s efforts to improve the transparency of the process came at the cost of integrity. Because if the government agency has no problems making private data public without permission, people may no longer bother to register next time.
There are much more effective ways to use the list of registered voters. The COMELEC could store all the data in a protected database. To access their personal information, registrants can prove their identity by logging in with their name and date of registration. The encoded list doesn’t stay unused in a hard disk somewhere, while privacy is maintained. Some naysayers may call such a system impossible to implement or secure. Yet given our world-class IT expertise, creating such an application, reasonably secure against hardware failure and hacking, will prove no problem.
It makes sense to post the election results online. But not to threaten a voter’s basic right to privacy—which lets him make a truly independent decision, free from excessive influence or threat of retaliation.
Update: the list has been taken down.








10 Responses to “What Price, Privacy?”
I wonder if the COMELEC’s own officials’ personal data info is also included in that list…
[...] What Price, Privacy? @ Bayanihan Blog Network added 2007.03.17 1750h [...]
[...] The Philippine Blogosphere is positively buzzing about the COMELEC posting a list of registered Filipino voters available online: [...]
They have taken down that particular webpage but when you search your name on google or other search engines,
YOU WILL STILL SEE EVERYTHING!
your address, birthday, full freaking name!!!!!!! aaahhhhh!!!
cant they do something about that?
Jonas Diego: If they included the officials’ personal info, then they really had good intentions.
wickedmonicker: I think it’s possible to ask search engines to remove a website from their index (and cache). Here’s an informative article on that. Apparently, you use a file called robots.txt to tell robots not to crawl a site…
[...] Some bloggers (myself included) criticized the COMELEC for making registered voters’ private info public [...]
can i have the list of voters from comelec, i am looking for a long lost friend Blesila Lunas,
i just wanted too look for mr macario aglanao. he is my uncle and its been a long time since we never see him.
pwedeko bang malaman ang address ng friend ko na si blesila lunas
can i have the list of voters from
comelec, i am looking for a long lost uncle Marcos Magdael
Leave a Reply